(This interview was originally published in the February 2020 edition of the GPWA Times Magazine)
Well, Andrew, you have been in the iGaming affiliate business for over a decade. We interviewed you for our May 2008 issue when you were a part-time affiliate and running your site as a part-time gig in addition to your full-time job.
Then in 2012 you were doing well enough to go full-time as an affiliate. You took on a staff, hired freelance copy writers and things seemed to be on the right track. But, for a variety of reasons, things didn’t go as planned since that time and today you are back to being a full-time worker and part-time affiliate. Can you please take us through what happened?
Yes, 2012 was our best year. As you say, we finally earned enough to be able to go full-time. Even got invited to an awards night as a guest of Betfair. At that point, it seemed like a reward for six years of hard work.
At the start of 2013, I decided to venture into different websites, looking at live dealers, Asian markets. Spent thousands on translations, etc. Looking back, I really should have invested that money into Fortune Palace, as that was what had generated the income, but at that point I felt diversification was a better plan.
In October 2013 I got hit with a Manual Action from Google for “unnatural links,?which saw rankings and income plummet. The issue was with links embedded in syndicated articles, which in 2006 was approved and widely used, but suddenly became against Google's TOCs. I had never bought links, and articles were my main way to obtain them organically.
I spent the next nine months trying to salvage rankings, disavowing links, resubmitting considerations every few weeks. I eventually got the penalty overturned, but rankings and income never really got back to the same level. Having said that, it was still earning enough to be happy with its performance.
But then things started to decline. I had the usual problems that all affiliates do ?committing to operators who turned out to be rogue, and with apparently legitimate operators, who suddenly dumped U.K. affiliates.
In the U.K., the Gambling Commission seems to have online gambling in its sights, so operators were rightly nervous, but possibly overreacted. bet365, for example (who remain a great partner) have restricted what affiliates can write about them to the point where all reviews just contain the same bland, non-factual information. The whole point of affiliate sites is to compare and contrast, so this becomes very difficult.
The need to display (terms and conditions) of bonuses at every point of mention made site design very clunky. For a while, I just removed all bonus offers, (which wasn't a great move!) but eventually redesigned the site to be able to include them. Still don't like the aesthetics, but it's now 100% compliant.
In 2019, the final nail in the coffin was the insistence on age verification for free play games. As it's impossible for an affiliate to do this, I had to remove them. Part of the initial ethos of the site was to allow users to practice strategies before committing to a casino and the free games generated a lot of traffic. Although these visitors were, by definition, non-transactional, there were enough of them that the small percentage that converted were worth having. That traffic stream is now gone.
Some of the things that worked against you were out of your control and unpredictable. But looking back, what would you have done different, if anything?
As I said above, I would have consolidated and expanded the site before trying to diversify. In the initial site design, I tried to find a niche, but probably limited things too much. I should have made it much broader, though time was always an issue. On that same topic, I should also have tried to network with others a bit earlier. Freelance copy writers, coders, designers, etc. all became essential to the ongoing running of the site, but I realized that too late, having tried to do it all myself for years.
Earlier this year you were approached by a company that wanted to buy the site. But, even after all you have been through, you decided against selling. Why?
Yes, I was very tempted. It was a decent offer, but I calculated the lifetime value of the site would be more than they were looking to pay. It's the old “bird in the hand?argument, but I always feel that things might pick up again and I'd regret cashing in too soon.
My mindset now is less positive (as you can see!) so I may still be tempted to sell if someone came in with a decent offer. I've put a lot of time and effort into the site and would be sad to see it go, but the right offer would compensate!
How do you see the role of a U.K. casino affiliate evolving over the next five years? How about the industry as a whole?
I honestly haven't a clue! If our role isn't to act as a “middle man,?offering impartial advice to consumers looking to make purchasing choices, I'm not sure what it is. I'm always happy to write “educational?articles, such as Blackjack Switch strategies, but if we can't ultimately help players choose casinos, there's not much value in it.
I know a lot of sites have gone down the “community?route, publishing people's individual reviews of sites, but from a user's perspective I always find those to be either shills or disgruntled punters who didn't read the terms and conditions of bonuses properly. If I’m ever buying something online, I'd always rather read a balanced pro and con review of the product by an independent researcher than user reviews or official press releases. That's what I felt the role of an affiliate should be, and was.
If someone told you they were thinking of trying to pull off exactly what you were doing in 2008 (working a full-time gig, while running an iGaming affiliate site on the side for extra income) what would you tell them if they asked for advice?
I'd probably advise them against it. I think the market has changed considerably since then and “Lone Ranger?affiliates are in competition with some serious organizations with lots of staff and huge advertising budgets. I'd suggest trying to network with other like-minded individuals who share a common strategy, but also have something unique to add to a very crowded marketplace.
What has your wife, friends and kids thought about this journey for you over the last 10 years?
They've all been interested. Friends are always curious to know the mechanics of how it works, and are always slightly incredulous when I explain! My wife has been there all the way through, from when it looked impossible, to when it took off, to where we are now. The kids have grown up with it, so they know that now and again a “casino bonus?means we can treat them to stuff or take them on holiday. To them, it's just a part of what I do.
You told us in our previous interview that one of the reasons you got into the industry is because you liked to gamble yourself. Do you still gamble?
I still gamble online, but only a few tens of pounds and just for entertainment. Mainly blackjack and baccarat, never slots! I'm also part of a poker group with five or six friends and we get together whenever we can, though it's not often enough.
Again, it's far more about the entertainment ?no one ever loses more than a few tens of pounds, but we have plenty of beer, pizza and laughs. Always great fun into the early hours.
You have mentioned that you sometimes struggle with the “morality?of making a living that depends on other people losing money and that’s a common thought process for a lot of affiliates. How do you cope with these thoughts? Does it get any easier the longer you are in the business?
If I'm honest, it's always bothered me and hasn't really eased over time. The rev-share model gives the potential for huge monthly wins (and losses!), but there's always that nagging sense that someone has lost it. I accept the argument that they'd probably have lost it anyway and at least they were playing at a regulated casino, with much tighter controls than playing FOBTs for cash in a high street bookmakers. But I'd still prefer a model where we got paid a percentage of deposits, rather than losses.
I understand that people have different views about the best way to monetize this industry, but I haven't found a way that makes me totally comfortable. On a GPWA thread I made the point that we were just encouraging gambling as a form of entertainment, but someone rightly said that we need those huge losers to really make anything out of this. If I left online gambling, I'd miss the income, but I think my conscience would be a little clearer.
What were you like in high school and what did you want to do as a profession as you were growing up?
Quite boring, to be honest! I didn't really enjoy school, but saw it as a means to an end so just put my head down for five years, did what I could and got through it.
For as long as I could remember, all I wanted to do was join the Royal Air Force as a pilot, so my studies were focused on that ?lots of math and science subjects. Nothing “artsy? In the end, I failed the medical due to an irregular heartbeat so that was the end of that! Spent the next few years trying to work out what to do with my life. Probably still haven't resolved it!
What are your hobbies?
I love walking and hiking. I think it's very important to get away from the noise and bustle of urban life and try to reconnect with nature. It's a bit like clearing your cache. I can get back to work with a slightly clearer mind, or at least a clearer focus on what's important.
I also have a lingering desire to be able to paint. I have all the equipment and have attended lots of courses, but still struggle to be happy with what I churn out! We buy a fair amount of original art work for the house and although I can produce something decent, I just feel I haven't got that spark of talent that I can see in other artists. But I'm still persevering, so I remain optimistic!
If someone from out of town were visiting you, what’s the one place you'd definitely take them to see?
We're very lucky in that we have some really gorgeous parts of the U.K. within an hour's drive. We can very quickly get to the Lake District, the Peak District and Snowdonia (National Park).
We're also less than an hour away from some decent-sized beaches if you fancy a walk by the sea. It can be bracing (code for cold and windy!) but also lovely in the summer. We're also very close to two big cities in Manchester and Liverpool so if anyone visits who's into boutique shopping or fine dining, we'll take them there. Similarly for those into soccer ?we're surrounded by Premier League teams and grounds if that's your thing! And we're less than two hours away by train from London.
So although there's not much in St. Helens per se, we're very well placed to cater for any visitors who come our way!
If you were stranded on a desert island, what three items would you take with you and why?
My espresso machine.
A solar panel to generate power for the espresso machine.
A huge, refrigerated, vacuum sealed pack of hundreds of kilos of freshly roasted coffee.
Why? I like coffee.
If you could invite any five people, living or dead, to dinner, who would they be?
Isaac Newton, Dalai Lama, Winston Churchill, Dara ?Briain, Miriam Margolyes.
Name three things that people reading this magazine don't know about you.
- I'm an ex professional opera singer.
- I'm a trained barista.
- I'm undertaking training for my private pilot license.